No Vote, No Mandate? FDA Opioid Meeting Shows Limits Of Non-Voting Panels

US FDA Commissioner Califf has proposed that the agency move away from ‘gladiator votes’ that frame advisory committee meetings as a yes-or-no decision on a single question and instead emphasize the importance of the expert discussion and nuance of regulatory issues. The latest high-profile advisory committee review of a key opioid response issue shows the challenges with that approach.

FDA no voting
Is this the best direction for FDA? • Source: Nielsen Hobbs; the Pink Sheet | Shutterstock images

US Food & Drug Administration officials routinely emphasize one key point in framing the questions they pose to their expert advisory committees: the agency values the discussion of the issues by the invited experts much more than the final count on any vote they may take.

Commissioner Robert Califf has urged that the agency apply that philosophy more directly, by holding more meetings that do not...

Pink Sheet Podcast

Learn what's happening at the US FDA. On the go.

Derrick Gingery and the team bring you a weekly "Drug Fix".

More from US FDA Performance Tracker

Ocaliva Confirmatory Trial Failed To Verify Benefit In Primary Biliary Cholangitis, US FDA Says

 
• By 

A real-world evidence study also does not meet the regulatory standard for an adequate and well-controlled clinical investigation, the agency said. The FDA should allow the accelerated approval drug to remain available like other treatments that failed their confirmatory trials, Intercept said.  

Recent And Upcoming FDA Advisory Committee Meetings

Recent and upcoming US FDA advisory committee meetings and a summary of the topics covered. 

EU Filings Tracker TEST

New marketing authorization applications filed with the European Medicines Agency's human medicines committee (the CHMP) for review under the EU's centralized procedure. Updated monthly.

US FDA Adcomm Reform Ideas: Neutral Facilitator As Chair, Public Hearing Lottery Process Tweaks

 
• By 

Proposal to have panelists rate the strength of efficacy and safety evidence on a numeric scale also draws support in written comments on ways to optimize the advisory committee process.

More from Regulatory Trackers

Ocaliva Confirmatory Trial Failed To Verify Benefit In Primary Biliary Cholangitis, US FDA Says

 
• By 

A real-world evidence study also does not meet the regulatory standard for an adequate and well-controlled clinical investigation, the agency said. The FDA should allow the accelerated approval drug to remain available like other treatments that failed their confirmatory trials, Intercept said.  

Global Pharma Guidance Tracker – August 2024

 
• By 

Stay up to date on regulatory guidelines from around the world with the Pink Sheet's Guidance Tracker. The complete Global Pharma Guidance Tracker, with sortable and searchable listings going back to 2014, is available online.

Recent And Upcoming FDA Advisory Committee Meetings

Recent and upcoming US FDA advisory committee meetings and a summary of the topics covered.